• Firm History
    • Films
    • My Lai
    • Abu Ghraib
    • Haditha
    • MARSOC
    • The Stryker 5
    • Gary Myers
  • Practice Areas
    • Military Law >
      • Court-martial Information >
        • Know Your Rights
        • Court-Martial Rules >
          • Pretrial Confinement
          • Unlawful Command Influence
          • Article 31 Violation
          • Military Rule of Evidence 412
          • Involuntary Statements
          • Failure to State an Offense
          • Wheeler Factors
      • Court-Martial Defense >
        • Military Sexual Assault Defense
        • Drug Defenses >
          • Marijuana
          • Cocaine
          • Morphine and Heroin
        • Disrespect Offenses
        • Conspiracy Cases
        • False Statements >
          • Obstruction of Justice
        • Use of Force
        • Assault Cases
        • Conduct Unbecoming
      • Court-Martial Appeals >
        • Petitions for a New Trial
        • Insufficient Evidence
    • Correcting Military Records >
      • Evaluation Report Appeals
      • Reprimand Appeals
      • Family Advocacy Program Appeals
      • Discharge Review Boards
      • Cadet Misconduct
      • Titling Actions
      • Military Protective Orders
    • Separation Boards
    • Military Medical Malpractice Claims
    • Forms, Downloads, and Regulations
  • Books
  • Sketches
  • Contact
  • Results
DANIEL CONWAY | MILITARY ATTORNEY

Article 134 Obstruction of Justice

Elements

​-
That the accused wrongfully did a certain act; 

-That the accused did so in the case of a certain person against whom the accused had reason to believe there were or would be criminal proceedings pending;

​-
That the act was done with the intent to influence, impede, or otherwise obstruct the due administration of justice; and,

​-
That, under the circumstances, the conduct of the accused was to the prejudice of good order and discipline in the armed force or was of a nature to bring discredit upon the armed forces. [1]  

Discussion
       
Obstruction of justice in the military encompasses a much broader prohibition on conduct than federal law.
[2] Plainly, the law contemplates efforts to interfere with administrative proceedings as well as criminal.  Obstruction can occur when the accused has reason to believe that criminal or administrative proceedings would occur.  In fact, the proceedings or investigation need not necessarily include proceedings or investigations under U.S. law. Scheitzer was a case in which a pilot involved in an aircraft mishap in Italy destroyed cockpit video from the flight.[3] In that case, the government charged the pilot with conduct unbecoming an officer for obstructing an Italian investigation. Though there was originally an identical obstruction of justice charge, he pleaded guilty to two conduct unbecoming offenses.
 
Obstruction cases can be highly fact dependent.  The mere attempt to conceal a crime without more may not be an obstruction of justice when officials are not yet aware of the offense.
[4]  Courts have historically looked for intent to subvert or corrupt the administration of justice.

Standard Instructions
DA Pamphlet 27-9
3-96-1 - Obstructing Justice[5]

3-96A-1 - Wrongful interference with an adverse administrative proceeding[6]
 
Maximum Punishment
 
The maximum punishment is a dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and confinement for five years.


Lesser Included Offenses
 
There are no stated lesser-included offenses in the manual.
 

[1] MCM, Pt. IV, ¶ 96a.

[2] United States v. Jones, 20 M.J. 38, 40 (C.M.A. 1985).

[3] United States v. Schweitzer, 68 M.J. 133 (C.A.A.F. 2009).

[4] United States v. Asfeld, 30 M.J. 917 (A.C.M.R. 1990); United States v. Gray, 28 M.J. 858 (A.C.M.R. 1989).

[5] Military Judges Benchbook, ¶ 3-96-1 - Obstructing Justice.

[6] Military Judges Benchbook, ¶ 3-96A-1 - Wrongful interference with an adverse administrative proceeding.
Myers, Conway Military Law
CALL 210-934-UCMJ
Email
Lawpay
Resources
Free Initial Consultations
Confidential. In depth. Valuable.

(210) 934-UCMJ
© COPYRIGHT 2019. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. 
The information on this page is informational in nature. Nothing on this or associated pages should be construed as legal advice for a particular case. Likewise, the information on this website does not constitute the creation of an attorney-client relationship. No representation is made that the quality of legal services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.
  • Firm History
    • Films
    • My Lai
    • Abu Ghraib
    • Haditha
    • MARSOC
    • The Stryker 5
    • Gary Myers
  • Practice Areas
    • Military Law >
      • Court-martial Information >
        • Know Your Rights
        • Court-Martial Rules >
          • Pretrial Confinement
          • Unlawful Command Influence
          • Article 31 Violation
          • Military Rule of Evidence 412
          • Involuntary Statements
          • Failure to State an Offense
          • Wheeler Factors
      • Court-Martial Defense >
        • Military Sexual Assault Defense
        • Drug Defenses >
          • Marijuana
          • Cocaine
          • Morphine and Heroin
        • Disrespect Offenses
        • Conspiracy Cases
        • False Statements >
          • Obstruction of Justice
        • Use of Force
        • Assault Cases
        • Conduct Unbecoming
      • Court-Martial Appeals >
        • Petitions for a New Trial
        • Insufficient Evidence
    • Correcting Military Records >
      • Evaluation Report Appeals
      • Reprimand Appeals
      • Family Advocacy Program Appeals
      • Discharge Review Boards
      • Cadet Misconduct
      • Titling Actions
      • Military Protective Orders
    • Separation Boards
    • Military Medical Malpractice Claims
    • Forms, Downloads, and Regulations
  • Books
  • Sketches
  • Contact
  • Results